Hello There!

Hello there!

I just stumbled across your blog and I love your posts! And when I saw that you also write for Creepypasta, I just had to send in a request, especially considering that there's barely anything there!

So may I ask for some general and romantic headcanons for Toby? I really love this guy!

I hope you have a wonderful day and remember to stay hydrated!

(Also, apologies if there are any mistakes, English isn't my native language ^^)

See ya! :D

Hi! Thank you, Vero, you stay hydrated and have a wonderful day as well! I'm so glad you love my stuff <3 I was just thinking about doing something for Toby, so you're in luck hehe

(Also, your English is amazing my friend. No worries <3)

• ───────────────── •

Content: Toby general and romantic headcanons with gender neutral reader

Warnings: Mentions of trauma, implied murder, implied violent bipolar episodes, obsessive behavior, toxic jealousy, toxic relationship, and implied familial trauma.

Notes: I come from the era of creepypasta where everybody believed Toby was very obsessed with waffles, and was horribly misinterpreted in fanfiction. That was about eight years ago now though, and from what I've seen the fandom has been getting better with representation of Toby.

I've put a lot of thought into this. Might use this as inspo to revamp my Jeff headcanon list.

• ───────────────── •

(art by Lynnarty on Deviantart)

❥General

I want to start by saying: I know almost nothing about Tourette's syndrome and don't know anybody who has it. If I get anything wrong, please please please correct me. I wanna get this right for you lovelies. Thank you <3

Now, what I do know about Tourette's, is that there are two types of tics: motor and phonic. I believe Toby has more motor tics than phonic. I know he's portrayed as stuttering and twitching/moving rapidly at the same time, but I don't think he has as many phonic tics as we think

I do however, think he has a natural stutter. He was bullied in grade school, and as a fellow bullied child, I can confidently say that he developed the stutter then. I will die on this hill.

His personality is also not at all that of a child, who spends all his time screaming and laughing just for the hell of it. He's unhinged, yeah, but not in the oblivious child way. More of the sadistic way for very obvious reasons.

He's more so reserved, just kinda comes and goes. There will be points in time where he decides to be super obnoxious and fuck with other pastas in the mansion, but that's moreso purposely picking fights and intentionally being annoying than whatever the hell fanfic writers wrote in the early 2010's.

He does have bipolar disorder, so he'll lose his shit when he decides to fuck with people and they fuck with him back. It turns ugly really fast.

With his CIPA (Cognitive Insensitivity to Pain), obviously he cannot feel when he gets injured on missions, or if his motor tics cause him any pain. He won't really give a shit if he finds an injury, and won't really take any steps to go to Eyeless Jack either to get patched up. Either someone else will have to bring him, or Jack will have to hunt him down himself.

Speaking of Jack, he was able to fix up the left side of Toby's mouth when he came to the mansion. Fixing Toby's injury and Jeff's face were the first two things he did.

Toby still chews on his hands and the insides of his mouth, just out of habit or if he's stressed/upset about something.

He doesn't have a reaction to fire, really. He doesn't like dwelling on the past + he's ready to just keel over and die at any moment, so it doesn't really matter to him.

Being called "Ticci Toby" angers him to no end. You will die if you call him that, no exceptions.

• ───────────────── •

❥Romantic

Toby didn't really look for love after joining the mansion

Like I mentioned above, he's ready to die at any point, so he finds it kinda pointless to get a partner if he's just gonna die soon

He noticed when you joined the mansion, but he didn't actually say anything to you until you'd been there for some months. He doesn't particularly associate himself with people in the first place, let alone people he newly "meets."

He's not very friendly at first, but being nice to him even through his obnoxious moments and horrendous mood swings and even going so far as to try to help him (he won't let you in the moment but he'll reflect on it later), it'll get you in his good graces

Being blindingly nice won't just get you in romantic territory. If he sees you being an actual person around others while just being super nice with him, it's going to make him think you're not genuine.

Just be yourself around him. When he sees you treat him the same as the others (with genuine kindness and respect) and not like he's some freak, it'll get you brownie points.

Toby doesn't realize he's insecure and thinks it's normal to get super jealous super easily. His parents didn't have the best relationship and most internet media of relationships is toxic in itself, so you'll have to be the one to sit down with him and lay out your boundaries. Even then, he'll frequently cross them.

It's not because he doesn't respect you or love you. He does. Just sometimes he wants to move the relationship a little faster, or he's impatient and wants kisses when you're with the others, or he's just plain forgetful.

Again on the jealous point though, he's going to get very upset if you don't notice he's jealous. In his mind, it's very obvious. Eventually he'll get so upset that he yanks you away from the people, cusses them out, then storms off with you and slams every door he goes through for extra measure. He's then going to cry as he holds you, apologizing and saying he didn't mean it and he was just scared you were going to leave him.

He doesn't let you be with your other pasta friends without lurking in the background, watching yours and their every move. He loves you and just wants to make sure you're okay. Happily accepts you back into his arms when you're done.

The only time you'll be able to hang out with friends outside the mansion (without him watching you) is when Toby is away on missions. If you befriend the right pastas, they'll cover for you. If he's not away though, he's very likely going to be stalking you and your friends in the background.

Toby doesn't care if you give him PDA or not, he just wants to be near you and do what he wants in the moment. Once he realizes he has feelings for you, he's going to be clinging to your side.

Loves when you show him physical affection and attention without him asking.

He also loves when you involve him in things you like. He might not participate in it, but the fact that you thought of him makes him happy. His favorite thing is eating some snacks while cuddling on his bed and watching some show you love.

Toby by himself just kinda exists. Toby in a relationship with you just kinda exists, but he wants people to know that you only exist with him.

For obvious reasons, Toby is a fucked up individual, and a relationship with him will always be toxic in some aspect. Everyone in the pasta mansion is fucked up, and very few will have healthy relationships. Yes, we love the pastas anyway, but we cannot fix them, so just keep that in mind lovelies <3

• ───────────────── •

Here is my Masterlist in case you want to request, or look for more of your favorite character!

me: wow its really hot today

friend: its not the heat that gets you, its the humidity

reiner braun: *gestures* im the armored titan and he's the colossal titan

What.

every few years I just like to remind people of this Yugioh fancast in an early 2000s magazine

…do…. Do people who leave bitchy comments on fanfics know that they don’t have to read the fic?

Like dog. Just don’t read it? Hello?

what if

Hi there! I just stumbled across your blog today and I really love what you've put out so far. I would like to put in a request myself, if that's okay?

Romantic headcanons with Jeff, Eyeless Jack and Toby; reader can gender neutral if you'd like, too.

As a fellow college student, I understand time is limited. Take as much time as needed with this. Have a wonderful day, stay safe and stay hydrated <3

-Redd

LOVE ME DEAD

♡LOVING YOU ROMANTICALLY | CREEPYPASTA | NOT EDITED

Includes: Jeff the Killer, Ticci Toby, Eyeless Jack

Jeff the Killer

His love is unreal. Almost like an obsession but you know it’s love, it’s supposed to be. You can feel it in the way he kisses you, the way he holds you, the way he looks at you.

Somehow, he manages to spoil you everyday.

Jewelry, clothing, souvenirs, anything really. But he only gets them when he leaves the house and does whatever it is he does. Well, aside from killing.

Very often, he brings you a piece of nature. Something to cook. Other times, he’ll cook it.

He’s an odd fella, especially with how he treats you. But he treats you right nevertheless.

Rough kisses, gripping your thighs or waist, making love. All of the above, Jeff will definitely show you and make you feel it. There’s nothing to sugarcoat with this man.

“Baby.” “Princess.” “Love.” Yes, even to his boyfriend, he’ll call him princess.

When he’s in love, he makes sure the world knows. He marks you right up and dares anyone to flirt with you.

A jealous man who does not mind watching another person shoot their shot. He just loves watching their face court into an expression of fear as soon as he swings an arm over your shoulder.

But at the end of the day, he will build you both a new home from the ground up if he must. Well, he already started.

Ticci Toby

Soft and gentle. He’s tired half the time and just wants someone to make him forget about his current life.

A sweetheart. Kisses your hands and cheeks everyday. Pulls you into tight embraces and reminds you that he loves you.

Whispers sweet nothings into your ear whenever he can. When he does, a trail of kisses will go down your neck. Teeth grazing against your skin with a soft bites.

He dares not to hurt you. His hand will rest on your waist with gentle squeezes, urging you to hold him back. To embrace him, to love him just a little more each day.

Everyday, he looks at you a certain way. It’s the same as every other time. Everyday, he wakes up in love again. You make him want to be alive.

For that, he takes you out. Far into the woods with a basket in hand—a picnic every weekend—sometimes a long adventure every time.

He’s the most patient and gentle lover out of all these killers. It’s almost pathetic.

Yet, the lovemaking is surreal. A pleasure dom, and he loves making you squeal again, and again, and again.

Kisses your hands every other hour. The tips of your fingers to the palm. He believes you should be treated with care.

Eyeless Jack

An old lover at heart, really.

Love letters written for you. As said in the other post, there’s nothing more to add about this man.

He’s just an old lover at heart. Flowers brought home for you, chocolate sweets awaiting on your bed, and a gentleman.

He would lie his jacket over a puddle for you.

Think of, Gomez Addams. That’s EJ in this case. Written poetry that tells his love like a story. Words upon words that can build you guys a new home to which, he became your home.

You become his home.

He bites and kisses your neck, showing a gentleness to it. He wants you to trust him that he will never harm you with those sharp teeth of his.

Homemade dinners at the table that has a single candlelit.

You, are his cup of wine.