Adding To My Series Of Hermione And Pyrrhus Being A Cute Couple, Small Husband Who Loves His Wife

Adding to my series of Hermione and Pyrrhus being a cute couple, small husband who loves his wife

This is what I’ve learned about haikaveh from the twitter tl let me know if it’s right

Actually, this brings up a point about Alhaitham that I want to address. (Well, technically I already addressed it loosely as the subject of a fic, but not as a Tumblr post.)

A few times I've seen notions along the lines of "Alhaitham cares, he just doesn't show it" -- which I think is on the right track and well-intentioned, but, by my personal reading of him as a character, not entirely accurate. It is, however, certainly more accurate than claims that he is cold or has no feelings.

I think Alhaitham is (or can be) a caring person, and while he doesn't necessarily show it in conventional ways, he does have his own personal ways of expressing it.

It's pretty clear from initially meeting him in Port Ormos that he's guarded around people he doesn't trust yet--he speaks formally, and his expression doesn't change much, aside from a brief smirk or smile of confidence whenever he realizes that his cooperation with the Traveler is "increasingly worth his investment." Overall, based solely on his dialogue and mannerisms, it's difficult to discern his thought patterns or his personality.

However, he isn't blatantly disrespectful or cold, either; in fact, I was struck by his courteousness: he thanks the Traveler for their efforts, offers them a break, and explicitly gives them permission to decline to answer a question or even to consent to working with him. In the one moment that he is duplicitous by pilfering the Divine Knowledge Capsule behind the Traveler's back, he earnestly recognizes and apologizes for it later.

I feel that, even though Alhaitham doesn't know the Traveler very well at this point, he does care about them, even if only to the extent that maintaining a relationship with them based on genuine trust is beneficial to him personally. Ditto for when he rescues the Traveler at Caravan Ribat; even if his interest in the Traveler only extends to their undisclosed information and not them as a person, he still goes out of his way to help them.

Now, fast forward to several parts of the Archon Quest later, right before the team returns to Sumeru City to execute their anti-Akademiya plan--only because, at this point, everyone on the Sumeru team has had lots of time to bond and converse, and, hence, I think the contrast between the Alhaitham we met at Port Ormos and the Alhaitham we know now is potentially the greatest.

Alhaitham smiles and teases the Traveler and Paimon. Mostly ALHAITHAM SMILES.

The way he conducts himself is markedly different from how he addressed the Traveler back in Port Ormos. Though he still speaks bluntly and firmly maintains his personal boundaries, his demeanor is more sensitive and expressive than it was before. I took this as a sign that he'd grown to trust and care about the Traveler more, as he's comfortable being more vulnerable around them; teasing usually bothers me, but I found this scene touching instead for that reason.

This scene is merely my case study, though; there are others--I've also written a post on, for example, how I believe the execution of the anti-Akademiya plan demonstrates the strength and depth of Alhaitham's faith in his teammates. Again, my point is that Alhaitham does show that he cares in an individual manner, even if social conventions would lead someone to believe superficially that he is "cold" or "callous." Alhaitham obviously has things that are precious and meaningful to him, like the books he kept after his parents passed away. Returning to the dialogue that prompted this post, his free time is obviously one of these precious and meaningful things, so I think sharing what he does is something highly significant to him personally. He's certainly not emotionless, and he's not uncaring, especially not once he has the chance to bond with and grow to trust someone.

I’m thinking about Song Of Achilles again and like….I cannot think of the logic behind how Madeline Miller wrote Pyrrhus (Neoptolemus).

Like, he was a cruel asshole in the myths, so she got that part down.

But she added the wrinkle of him being raised by Thetis and did….nothing with it.

He quite literally exists solely to be a hate sink and to drag the plot out just a little longer.

Maybe he exists to give Thetis some form of redemption, by having her correct his big mistake.

But that raises even more questions because Thetis had been filling the role Pyrrhus had nearly the entire book. Pyrrhus may exists to show why its a good thing Thetis didn’t raise Achilles, but that is never the focus.

As far as the book is concerned, Pyrrhus is just a hate sink like Thetis (until the end) or Agamemnon to throw onscreen to get in the way of Achilles and Patroclus’ happy ending, and the inherent tragedy of him being a twisted Achilles or him being thirteen fucking years old by the time he’s onscreen is never touched upon.

Pyrrhus quite literally exists solely to be a replacement hate-sink for Thetis, and to provide some damn-near unearned last minute redemption for her.

Was Pyrrhus an ass in the original myths? Yes. Does that mean Madeline Miller could have wasted a potentially interesting character so she could throw in yet another one-note hate sink? Absolutely.

Random headcanon about Odysseus: we all know that he introduces himself as "Son of Laertes" but after Penelope, he def called himself "husband of Penelope" and after Telemachus was born, we all know he called himself "father of Telemachus". What can we say? He's a proud son/husband/dad.