HobbitSpaceCase on ao3. They/them.

1525 posts

So A Few Months Ago There Was The Discourse About Would You Rather Meet A Man Or A Bear In The Woods.

So a few months ago there was the discourse about would you rather meet a man or a bear in the woods. I didn't want to touch it while the discourse was hot and everyone dug in hard because those are not good conditions for nuance, but I waited until today, June 1st, for a specific reason.

I'm not going to take a position in the bear vs man debate because I don't think it matters. What is really being asked here is how afraid are you of men? Specifically, unexpected men who are, perhaps, strange.

People have a lot of very real fear of men that comes from a lot of very real places. Back when I was first transitioning in 2015 and 2016, I decided to start presenting as a woman in public even though I did not pass in the slightest.

I live in a red state. I knew other trans women who had been attacked by men, raped by men. I knew I was taking a risk by putting myself out there. I was the only visibly trans person in the area of campus I frequented, and people made sure I never forgot that. Most were harmless enough and the worst I got from them was curious stares. Others were more aggressive, even the occasional threat. I had to avoid public bathrooms, of course, and always be aware of my surroundings.

I know how frightening it is to be alone at night while a pair of men are following behind you and not knowing if they are just going in the same direction or if they want to start something - made all the worse for the constant low level threat I had been living under for over a year by just being visibly trans in a place where many are openly hostile to queer people. You have to remember, this was at the height of the first wave of bathroom law discussions, a lot of people were very angry about trans women in particular. My daily life was terrifying at times. I was never the subject of direct violence, but I knew trans women who had been.

I want you to keep all that in mind.

So man or bear is really the question "how afraid of men are you?", and the question that logically follows is "What if there was a strange man at night in a deserted parking lot?" or "What if you were alone in an elevator with a man?" or "What if you met a strange man in the woman's bathroom?"

My state recently passed an anti trans bathroom bill. The rhetoric they used was about protecting women and children from "strange men", aka trans women.

Conservatives hijack fear for their bigoted agenda.

When I first started presenting as a woman the campus apartment complex was designed for young families. The buildings were in a large square with playgrounds in the center, and there were often children playing. I quickly noticed that when I took my daughter out to play, often several children would immediately stop what they were doing and run back inside. It didn't take me long to confirm that the parents were so afraid of "the strange man who wears skirts" that their children were under strict instructions to literally run away as soon as they saw me.

"How afraid are you of a strange man being near your children?"

I mentioned above that I had to avoid public bathrooms. This was not because of men. It was because of women who were so afraid of random men that they might get violent or call someone like the police to be violent for them if I ever accidentally presented myself in a way that could be interpreted as threatening, when my mere presence could be seen as a threat. If I was in the library studying and I realized that it was just me and one other woman I would get up and leave because she might decide that stranger danger was happening.

Your fear is real. Your fear might even come from lived experiences. None of that prevents the fact that your fear can be violent. Women's fear of men is one of the driving forces of transmisogyny because it is so easy to hijack. And it isn't just trans women. Other trans people experience this, and other queer people too. Racial minorities, homeless people, neurodivergent people, disabled people.

When you uncritically engage with questions like man or bear, when you uncritically validate a culture of reactive fear, you are paving the way for conservatives and bigots to push their agenda. And that is why I waited until pride month. You cannot engage and contribute to the culture of reactive fear without contributing to queerphobia of all varieties. The sensationalist culture of reactive fear is a serious queer issue, and everyone just forgot that for a week as they argued over man or bear. I'm not saying that "man" is the right answer. I am saying that uncritically engaging with such obvious click bait trading on reactive fear is a problem. Everyone fucked up.

It is not a moral failing to experience fear, but it is a moral responsibility to keep a handle on that fear and know how it might harm others.

  • sodacaps
    sodacaps liked this · 11 months ago
  • titania-saturnine
    titania-saturnine reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • titania-saturnine
    titania-saturnine liked this · 11 months ago
  • dream-world-universe
    dream-world-universe liked this · 11 months ago
  • inqnel
    inqnel liked this · 11 months ago
  • kafkaesque-meat
    kafkaesque-meat reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • kafkaesque-meat
    kafkaesque-meat liked this · 11 months ago
  • itwasanangryinch
    itwasanangryinch reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • valence-drive
    valence-drive liked this · 11 months ago
  • demos-cloud
    demos-cloud reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • kittyishere0
    kittyishere0 liked this · 11 months ago
  • rainingmoondrops
    rainingmoondrops reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • rainingmoondrops
    rainingmoondrops liked this · 11 months ago
  • starredhalo
    starredhalo liked this · 11 months ago
  • asjjohnson
    asjjohnson reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • minakittengaming
    minakittengaming reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • miss-rum-hee
    miss-rum-hee reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • third-thoughts
    third-thoughts liked this · 11 months ago
  • comefromtheforest
    comefromtheforest reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • comefromtheforest
    comefromtheforest liked this · 11 months ago
  • salroka
    salroka liked this · 11 months ago
  • ihaveahordingproblem
    ihaveahordingproblem reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • samukai
    samukai liked this · 11 months ago
  • ihaveahordingproblem
    ihaveahordingproblem liked this · 11 months ago
  • dreamofbecoming
    dreamofbecoming reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • hesterbeckoned
    hesterbeckoned liked this · 11 months ago
  • mnlychee
    mnlychee reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • frogboyo
    frogboyo reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • multifandomgenius-blog
    multifandomgenius-blog liked this · 11 months ago
  • thisfireflyandaphoenix
    thisfireflyandaphoenix reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • miss-rum-hee
    miss-rum-hee reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • prinxe-with-no-crown
    prinxe-with-no-crown reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • mushroom-soup-is-my-religion
    mushroom-soup-is-my-religion reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • catamaurrr-star
    catamaurrr-star reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • visiblesideblog
    visiblesideblog reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • junnananas
    junnananas reblogged this · 11 months ago
  • b4734059gmailcom
    b4734059gmailcom liked this · 11 months ago
  • xxproxyinthedarkxx
    xxproxyinthedarkxx liked this · 1 year ago
  • planetary-ecologist
    planetary-ecologist reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • scp-stuff-is-pog
    scp-stuff-is-pog liked this · 1 year ago
  • theabnomancer
    theabnomancer liked this · 1 year ago
  • hedgehogherd
    hedgehogherd reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • barnablogja
    barnablogja reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • hedgehogherd
    hedgehogherd liked this · 1 year ago
  • coffin-clown
    coffin-clown liked this · 1 year ago
  • merganfm
    merganfm reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • spiders-hth-is-an-outlier
    spiders-hth-is-an-outlier liked this · 1 year ago
  • kaz2y5tiel
    kaz2y5tiel reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • kaz2y5tiel
    kaz2y5tiel liked this · 1 year ago

More Posts from Spacecasehobbit

1 year ago

how to have a healthier relationship with your stats page

1. Understand what stats can tell you - and what they can’t

AO3 stats tell you whether or not another user clicked something. That’s it. Hits tell you whether a user clicked the title of your fic. Kudos tell you that a user clicked the little ❤ at the bottom of the page. Comments tell you that a user typed something into a box and then hit the comment button. 

Stats do not tell you why a person did any of those things. They also don’t tell you why a person didn’t do them. You know why you do those things yourself, but there are many types of people in the world and we all have our reasons why we do things. You can’t assume that every other user of AO3 uses the site the same way you do. 

Stats are not a reliable way to find out if you’re good at writing. They’re not a way to tell if you are loved. They have nothing to do with the quality of your work or your worth as a person.

2. Don’t compare yourself to others - or yourself

Because stats are not a reliable way to judge quality or skill or the effort you put into a story, comparing your stats against another author will also not tell you which of you is the “better” author or which of you has a “better” story. They can tell you which story was more popular, but popularity itself has very little to do with skill or quality. 

This is also true of your own work. Chances are very real that the story you’re most proud of is not the story with the best stats. Don’t let one story’s relative success or failure affect how you feel about another’s. 

3. Focus on things you can control instead of things you can’t

Once you’ve posted your story, the reaction to it is out of your control. It will get however many hits, kudos, and comments other people decide to give it and you can’t do much about that at all. 

What you can control, however, is the work you put into the story before you post it. Celebrate statistics like word count or time spent writing or the number of WIP you’ve managed to finish. Those are all numbers that are in your control, that you have the power to alter and affect. 

Find something in every story that makes you happy. It doesn’t have to be the whole fic. It could be one particular characterization, a scene, or a line. Maybe you wrote a particularly funny joke or a really moving description or a hot love scene. 

Highlighting positive emotions and being proud of your own work will make you less reliant on the opinions of other people. You’ll develop more confidence, and that will help you avoid the stats spiral in the future. Finding motivations inside of yourself is much more reliable than getting motivation from people who might or might not continue to provide it.

4. If you can’t ignore stats, avoid them

The first time I had an unhealthy relationship with my stats page, I ended up quitting fic entirely for about a year. I still wrote, I just didn’t post anything on AO3. I couldn’t trust myself not to focus on the numbers and make myself crazy, and so I didn’t allow myself to look at them at all. 

The second time I found myself starting down the stats spiral, I knew the signs and I was able to pull myself out of it. I stopped looking at my stats page, but I was able to continue posting work. I still refreshed the page for the first day to see the hits/kudos/comments but after that first day I only returned to the fic in order to post a new chapter or answer another comment. 

There are tools you can use to help you avoid stats. This AO3 skin hides stats entirely. This code hides hits. Here’s one for hiding kudos with additional instructions on how to hide any stats you choose. 

5. Be your own cheerleader

When it comes right down to it, the reason why we focus in on stats is because we’re looking for reassurance. We want to know for sure whether we’re a good writer or not. Unfortunately, our stats are never going to tell us that. 

A lot of us are also told by others that being proud of something we’ve done or liking something that we’ve created is boastful or bragging or other negative personality traits. But there’s a difference between bragging about how good you are and acknowledging your own skills. 

Give yourself permission to like your own work. You might never get that permission from someone else, so you need to take that on yourself. 

Start talking to yourself the way you’d talk to a friend of yours who was working on a fic or a piece of art or doing anything else that requires time and skill. You wouldn’t tear them down, so don’t tear yourself down. Build yourself up. That positive self-talk can be difficult at first, but it’s a habit that pays off over time. 

6. Know that I’m proud of you

It takes courage and strength and determination to have an idea and then to act on it. It’s easy to think. It’s a lot harder to write things down. No matter whether you post your story online or you keep it to yourself. No matter whether you get a thousand hits or a dozen. You’re still amazing, and I’m so glad you took that leap ❤


Tags :
1 year ago
This One Is So Old I Don't Even Remember When I Started But Tried Finishing It Today. Still Experimenting

This one is so old I don't even remember when I started but tried finishing it today. Still experimenting on how to blend skintones with pastels. Also I don't even go here, I haven't even watched this movie, but I saw a lot of pretty gifs and fanart and his look captivated me so here we are XD


Tags :
1 year ago

.


Tags :
not the most important of rants but as a nonbinary trans person i kind of hate how much JKR and Harry Potter have become the face of “transphobia” honestly so much of the hp hate feels so performative without actually doing anything meaningful to fight everyday transphobia anywhere and i extra hate how it lumps together every trans person under this banner of 'you are hurting *me* personally if you still like jkr or hp' even though i as a trans person would much rather focus on how the main themes of hp are all in direct contradiction to jkr's modern stance on trans rights since they are messages all about inclusion and acceptance and not judging people just because they were born different than you and came late to 'your' culture or the fact that when jkr first wrote hp she herself was a struggling single mother living on welfare and how maaaybe there could be a conversation in there about how wealth and power can corrupt people and how fundamentally decent people can grow in negative ways not just in positive ways if you let yourself forget how it feels to be 'the little guy' (or if you get too focused on *staying* 'the little guy' when you maybe are not anymore) (or not the littest guy in a given conversation) instead of the performative 'you cannot like hp or interact with it at all in any public way OR ELSE' that has actually happened i am trans i hate who jkr has become but i still love harry potter and what it meant to me in my childhood and i refuse to let other people take that away for objectively nonsensical reasons that are never applied consistently across the board to other authors