I Seriously Think This Is How He Lost His Eye - Tumblr Posts

Ok, you guys have probably already figured this out, but I have a theory....

What if Captain Crow lost his eye BECAUSE OF A PREVIOUS DEAL WITH GWEN BATTERBIE?

Hear me out, when the Captain went to get the Hand of God from Batterbie, she said something like,

"I know why you're here, it's always the same reason, Captain."

When she said "it's always the same reason.", what if he and his crew have been tasked with the bounty of the red Bluster, and he failed so many times, that he eventually went to Batterbie... maybe she gave him something, and for the price, its was something valuable? And therefore, his eye got lost?

End of theory.

Edit: I know it was the Red Bluster, but maybe batterbie had something to do with it. Remember when she charged the Hand of God for everything that Crow had? In the end, even if she wasnt there, Crow lost everything. So yeah, maybe she priced something in the past for something valuable from him, and therefore, she took his eye.