Just Put A Reply If You Want Me To Explain Something About This Theory - Tumblr Posts

As funny as the "The fault lies with you, Ahab!!" memes are, I gotta say that Cathy probably took Ishmael's place in the Pequod Captain Fishmael Mirror world.

There's not much backing for this theory, but I think it makes the most sense, mostly once you see the CG with Queecliff in Canto VI's ending and with the... [ahem] Queequeg×Ishmael implications and the fact that Heathcliff×Cathy would be real if it weren't for their lack of communication. (< I would rant about these 2 but this is this and that's that.)

(I would put a "The fault lies with you, ___!" but I don't feel like thinking up a version of it that would make sense in this context, sorry.)