Lucifer X Reader X Alistair - Tumblr Posts

Idk of your interested in this idea. But I know you wrote an Alistair and Angel dust having feelings for the same S/O. What do you think it would be like if Alistair and Lucifer have feelings for the same fem s/o? Just want to add that fem s/o is a cat demon assassin who is strong as an overlord, but she is not an overlord. She doesn't believe in higher power.

📻 Alastor x fem!Reader x Lucifer Morningstar headcanons Cat demon assassin🐍

Alastor knew about you even before he disappeared for seven years. You were one of the most powerful sinners he knew. You were no weaker in strength than him or Rosie, and you clearly could have subdued no fewer souls than overlords, but you didn't need it. Alastor liked you and he was sure that nothing had happened to you in the seven years that he had been on vacation. Your appearance at the hotel pleased him, but the fact that you attracted Lucifer's attention did not please him

You lived in a hotel and often went about your business. You were like a cat walking by itself. Alastor knew that you were an assassin and that's why you left the hotel. Lucifer didn't know it, but he liked talking to you. You didn't pay attention to the fact that he was the king of Hell. You did not recognize the higher powers, treating others by their actions and not by their social status. Lucifer liked that about you and was happy to spend time with you, but the fact that Alastor seemed to be deliberately trying to stop him didn't make him happy at all

Alastor and Lucifer often communicated with you at the same time, but from the outside it looked like they were arguing in front of you. You didn't pay much attention to it, but the others only saw their arguments. They didn't want to let someone else take your attention, but you usually left without giving them an answer, hiding in the streets

They both watched you a lot. You knew it, but you ignored it, and only your tail, twitching from side to side, made it clear that you felt their gazes. They both intended to keep fighting for your heart

Lucifer and Alastor knew you differently. One has known you for a long time and knew your dark side, the other has known you only recently, but this did not prevent him from seeing your personality and realizing that he likes spending time with you. They were both confident that they could tame your loner nature, but they weren't going to give in to each other