Marchel John - Tumblr Posts
Hi. m bored so let's discect some traitor theories..
We'll go from least possible to most. (In my humble objectivly correct opinion)
So first rudith:
Is on lizzie's ship.
A particularly new recruite
Said he wasn't for living on the sea yet joined her
Was sort of upfront about his backstory
Noone suspects him or think of him first
Now. As you can see, you can argue all these points of evidence can be reasoned as otherwise, I'm sure someone can explain him as the plant better, however until then I think he just got envolved and didn't leave so he's just there now.
Therefore, caspian?
Well he is on lizzie's ship
Apparently been there since shadow beard
Stuck with her and knows everything she does
Told his backstory to gillion no issues
Knew edyn someway (she has an involvement with navy)
Now I don't know about you, but this guy doesn't sound too suspicious to me. Like, he even sounded nervous when the pearl told him "very doubtful" abt whether the war will succeed and probably saved lizzie a few too many times. Also I'm mainly about how he was on shadow beard's ship with lizzie before their own, besides, he's chill.
So now, for the main culprit.. Marchel john.
Now forget the bullet points thing, we're talking business. Cuz if jay could be easily put undercover to go with chip, then he sure as hell can tear off his sleeves in the chaos of rebellion and wave to the pirate that literally gave him the trust on a silver platter. BECAUSE GILLION JUST FUCKING TRUSTED HIM. Why? We'll never know. But isn't it so absolutely possible with how he didn't really go with him at first but in the chaos of the uproar gillion caused there was an opportunity and he took it? Abandoning his crew for the perfect chance. Not only that, he might have already gotten the idea from seeing lizzie first, being a first, eager recruite sounds like an important trustworthy role. Not only that but when he joined her crew he was meant to be their GUIDE. Like he knows every move because he's making them. Don't even get me started on offering gillion a conch when they meet again. This was his conch but also a navy conch that could be possiblly detected someway. Also, and I can't stress this enough, and even though it was with caspian too it was slightly more gradual where they spend time together before becoming bros and meeting eydn through caspian was probably what put him so high. But with John, THE GUY HAD TO DO LITERALLY NOTHING TO EARN HIS TRUST. Like caspian was an undersea person and so was familiar. But John was literally NAVY. He just jumped on this war bandwagon too eagerly. And I'm not saying he's an evil mastermind discuised as a himbo. But all I'm saying is smart himbos that are devoted enough to somebody, some leader perhaps, are one deadly fucking weapon.
There's no conclusion, speculate if you want.