Omitb Theories - Tumblr Posts

List of people whom I suspect could possibly be the murderer this season

OMINTB Season 4x4 Spoilers below

Professor Dudenoff:

His whole identity seems suspicious and the westies could be his henchmen of sorts. There’s definitely something more they’re hiding from Mabel because the idea of subletting the apartments seems too convenient. He could very well be someone who was affected a lot by Charles in the past during his TV star days. Maybe another actor who lost a major role like Brazzos to Charles.

Bev Melon:

I know that it seems too obvious given how episode 4 ended but I think there’s more to her craziness than she lets on. The following episode might possibly mislead us to believe that it’s not her or she could be one of the many people involved in the whole thing but I think she might just ‘do it to make the plot interesting’ because remember how the Hollywood writers wrote the Gang’s characters are dull and lifeless. So I feel she would do something like that for the plot to thicken lol.

Glen (Ben’s body double):

When we are first introduced to Glen he accuses the gang of the reason Ben got swept into theatre ultimately killing him. And when Charles goes to the bar again as Sazz’s double he replaces a real bottle amongst the props. While he did say something along the lines of how Sazz would have loved the chaos that followed after using the real bottle to hit Charles, he might have a hidden agenda. Because if you remember Season 3, Ben and Charles hated each other. And Glen might be aware of that too hence wanting to take revenge for Ben.

Someone else we already met but was kind of a forgettable character:

I strongly believe that we have met the killer already because of how twisted this season started out lol. Can’t wait to watch the remaining episodes in the coming weeks!!

OMG this makes total sense, this season’s twists and turns are perfectly paced that it keeps you guessing.

OMITB S4E4

My current running theory that I'm certain will be debunked next episode based on the final scene of this one:

The one-sided relationship Sazz wanted to get away from according to that chiropractor is one she had with Bev Melon, who perhaps was her past boss and was just as pushy and disrespectful towards her as she is with the gang right now about the OMITB movie. I can't think of any other reason Bev Melon would know of Sazz's trampoline park if they didn't have some sort of history together.

This is exactly what came to mind too. And Bev is definitely crazy plus I’m pretty sure we have already met the killer in episode one

Updated OMITB S4 Killer Theory

After watching this week's episode I have a new theory for who killed Sazz. There are some plot holes proving otherwise but for now this is what is sticking with me the most. I think it also ties some of these storylines together. I'm putting this all under a spoiler tag just in case since it hasn't been a full day yet.

I think Bev is actually Dudenoff. From what we know so far, Dudenoff is rarely ever home and is currently in Portugal. Bev living and working in Los Angeles means that she could go back and forth collecting rent, hire someone to do so, or just have it deposited directly. Maybe she inherited one of the apartments, saw an opportunity for the others and took it. Plus it's a nice side hustle that can help to fund her film projects.

The mysterious person in the group with their face scratched out could very well be Helga. Vince said that Helga was the wrong type of weirdo and Rudy, Inez, and Ana were all trying to paint her as mentally ill and paranoid. I think we can assume she's not dead since we heard her on the radio, but she is clearly in hiding meaning she didn't leave the West Tower on her own accord. I think she uncovered a secret about Dudenoff or whatever other crime these Westies are into and was going to tell Charles so he could expose it on the podcast.

Sazz was digging around searching for clues before she was killed, even going so far as to discover that someone was watching Charles and gaining access to the code for the Dudenoff apartment. This season has been playing around a lot with the concept of stunt doubles, twins, and actors portraying actors. What if Sazz bore a strong resemblance to Helga and was successfully able to pass as her which is how she got entry to the Dudenoff apartment? If the theory that Helga was going to snitch is correct, maybe during the night of the party one of the Westies looked out the window, saw Sazz in Charles' apartment and thought she was Helga and killed her to keep her from telling?

If Bev is Dudenoff there is a possibility that she was in attendance at the party at the end of season 3 and was also in town to collect the rent owed by the Westies. Maybe at the party she saw Sazz and because of the Sazz/Helga lookalike theory thought Helga was in disguise to get close to Charles. Having her side hustle exposed would lose her money and with how she hounded the trio to sign over their movie rights she sounds like she's struggling financially. In episode 4, the actors are referred to as faces because there's a dynamic where stunt people don't get recognition for their work and aren't recognized outside of the work that they do. At the party when they discuss the wine Charles has upstairs, Bev could have overheard that Sazz was going up to get it and saw that as her chance to strike. As Dudenoff it would be easy to run over to the apartment she owns and gain access to get the job done. Plus we now know she knows how to handle a gun after she is seen holding the trio at gunpoint at the end of the episode.

The question remains whether Sazz was the intended victim or Charles and I'm still going to go with Sazz for now. I know there's the whole "Everybody hates Charles" agenda but he's basically a homebody so I doubt there would be enough interactions over time for someone to actually hate him. The only other reason is that a family member of one of the victims in the podcast or the killers is mad at him for profiting off of their death like what the bartender said at Concussions.

So this is where I'm at right now theory wise. There is still plenty of time to change that because we have 6 episodes left. I know there's so much more to be discovered so I can't wait to see what direction the show will take over the next few episodes.

I may be looking a little too much into this but, marzipan pigs are gifted in German culture. The surname Dudenoff has German origins and the woman on the 445 frequency sounded like she had a German accent. Maybe I'm just crazy but I thought that was a strange connection lol

OMITB spoiler musings ahead

Oliver is right, what is with all the hams? The ham radios (the one from the Dudenoff apartment, Christmas guy's, whoever answered Mabel's call, and ghost Sazz said she had one), the ham in the Sauce family bathtub, the pig in the Dudenoff bathtub... it has to be significant that Sazz mentioned ham radio, right?