daoismdiscussions - Daoism Discussions
Daoism Discussions

Enjoy the vinegar, explore the Path.

122 posts

Truth And Arrogance

Truth and Arrogance

No matter how the wind howls, the mountain cannot bow to it.

When I was a child, I thought this was an issue of pride, of "face" as we say in Chinese culture. That the emperor was a divine symbol of the Chinese people, that to bow in submission to a conqueror would do nothing but forfeit the soul of the kingdom to shame. Perhaps this is still partly true. After all, it's not as if other lives would be spared had the emperor chosen to humiliate himself, while much (if not all) of the respect and faith placed in him by the people would have been lost. Perhaps the emperor had already recognized that Shan Yu had returned with little more than a hunting party, not even capable of conquering a single city, much less all of China.

But there's more to it than simply putting on a strong face, I think. There's that line that's tossed around in films constantly, "We do not negotiate with terrorists." To negotiate means to recognize the other party as at least some kind of equal. And while this may or may not be true in the case of real-life issues of terrorists, in the context of Disney's Mulan I believe it's more a question of universal truths. Shan Yu, having taken the castle by storm and cornered the emperor, asks not for a display of equality, but for submission, to prove his worth as a mighty warrior and conquering lord. But what authority does the emperor recognize in Shan Yu? A powerful leader and dangerous foe, of course, but these things mean little to him. Threatening his life means little as well in the grand scheme of the universe, a truth which eludes Shan Yu to the end.

A telling reversal occurs at the finale when the emperor bows to Mulan, heroine of the day and savior of China. He bows to her before her wisdom, her tenacity, and her virtue. These are things he recognizes as worthy of his respect and humility. The mountain, it would seem, will only bow when it has something greater than itself to bow to.

  • jconrad69
    jconrad69 reblogged this · 12 years ago
  • jconrad69
    jconrad69 liked this · 12 years ago
  • fireofspring
    fireofspring reblogged this · 12 years ago
  • fireofspring
    fireofspring liked this · 12 years ago

More Posts from Daoismdiscussions

12 years ago

Living with a Chronic Disease (by hankschannel)

Beautiful words by Hank Green on accepting reality and moving forward with optimism and strength. This is Daoism in action.

12 years ago
Someday Id Like To Write A Book About Death.

Someday I’d like to write a book about death. 

12 years ago

Changing the Moment to Be in the Moment

or, Stepping Off the Path to See the Path or, How Habit Doesn't Equate to Harmony

Well, today marks the beginning of another semester. Even though I've been very sleepy all day from working all night, it's good to be back at school. The professor had us go through a very interesting exercise today, one that really made me stop and think for a moment. After some general warm up figure studies, he asked us all to switch gears and draw a 15 minute pose with our non-dominant hand. As you can probably imagine, we were all pretty stunned at first, and then incredibly resistant to the idea. It was awkward, it was mind-bending, and it felt more than a little foolish. But we all wanted to be professional and see the task done.

After the pose finished, we took a break from drawing and he had everyone do a quick walk around the room to see the work of our classmates. Unbelievably, the majority of the work was fantastic, on par or even better than the drawings we had done earlier in the class with our dominant hand. The professor explained in thus: because of the strangeness, because of how sure we all were about how terrible the piece would look, we all subconsciously pay that much more attention to what we are drawing. Every line suddenly becomes of the utmost importance as we struggle to make the charcoal go where we want it to go on the paper. By putting ourselves in the most uncomfortable of situations, we are forced to exist entirely within the present moment, unable to be distracted by the day-to-day musings that we can generally handle while drawing normally.

Of course, the goal of this exercise wasn't to convince us to draw off-hand forever. The main point, as he put it, was to apply this mode of thinking every time we go back to drawing, especially when we switched back to our dominant hand in the next pose. Every stroke is important, every shape is vital. We cannot let ourselves get too habituated in our present situation, or we risk wandering off the Path without ever realizing it. Always mind the present waking moment, even when doing something we've done a thousand times before. Chop wood, carry water.


Tags :
12 years ago

Did you know that my surname is actually translated as Tsuba? In Chinese it's "Tan," but the character is identical. Apparently it's a very uncommon surname, and one of these days I hope to find a Chinese scholar or historian who might shed some light on my family's history. As an artist, I have wondered if perhaps my lineage had some sort of cosmic influence on my chosen profession. But, as the nature of paths go, it works out both ways. Either I was destined to love my craft from the time of my forefathers, or I was destined to blaze my own trail away from the intricate hilt carvings of my ancestors.

daoismdiscussions - Daoism Discussions
12 years ago
Music Makes For An Apt Analogy To Daoism, And If It Wasn't For Joining Band In Middle School, I Doubt

Music makes for an apt analogy to Daoism, and if it wasn't for joining band in middle school, I doubt that I would even be half as enriched as I am today, and hardly likely to have even thought of such an analogy. Not only the power of music, but the power of music education and the camaraderie of playing in a group; the benefits these things have for our children are beyond words (although I will continue to do my best). The discipline, dedication, and pursuit of excellence that comes from studying an instrument teaches us that with hard work we can achieve great things by ourselves. The harmony and collaboration required to play in an orchestra, band, or ensemble teaches us that through cooperation and respect we can create beauty as a team. And the leadership skills necessary to conduct a performance or direct a section or even just teach a chord to a new student teaches us that the next generation will always be there waiting for us to pass on what we've learned.

If you're interested in doing more for school music programs, find out what schools in your area need from the community. It could be as simple as just spreading the word, or it could be raising donations for new equipment. VH1's Save the Music program is a good place to start if you need one, but a simple phone call to your nearest public school could be just as good.

Reblog if band has changed your life.