feministdm - Cave Woman
Cave Woman

Ciswoman, aroace, thirties, nerd, student

1800 posts

On The Issue Of Theq Slur...

On the issue of the ‘q slur’...

So, yesterday, I got into a rather stupid internet argument with someone who was peddling what seemed to me to be a rather insidious narrative about slur-reclamation. Someone in the ensuing notes raised a point which I thought was interesting, and worrying, and probably needed to be addressed in it’s own post. So here we go:

image

The word ‘queer’ itself seems to be especially touchy for many, so let me begin to address this by way of analogy.

Instead of talking about “queer”, let’s start by talking about “Jew” - a word which I believe is very similar in its usage in some significant ways.

Now, the word “Jew” has been used as a derogatory term for literally hundreds of years. It is used both as a noun (eg. “That guy ripped me off - what a dirty Jew”) and as a verb (eg. “That guy really Jew-ed me”). These usages are deeply, fundamentally, horrifically offensive, and should be used under no circumstances, ever. And yet, I myself have heard both, even as recently as this past year, even in an urban location with plenty of Jews, in a social situation where people should have known better. In short – the word “Jew”, as it is used by certain antisemites, is – quite unambiguously – a slur. Not a dead slur, not a former slur – and active, living slur that most Jews will at some point in their life encounter in a context where the term is being used to denigrate them and their religion. 

Now here’s the thing, though: I’m a Jew. I call myself a Jew. I prefer that all non-Jews call me a Jew – so do most Jews I know. “Jew” is the correct term for someone who is part of the religion of Judaism, the same way that “Muslim” is the correct term for someone who is part of the religion of Islam, and “Christian” is the correct term for someone who is part of the religion of Christianity. 

In fact, almost all of the terms that non-Jews use to avoid saying “Jew” (eg. “a member of the Jewish persuasion”, “a follower of the Jewish faith”, “coming from a Jewish family”, “identifying as part of the Jewish religion”, etc) are deeply offensive, because these terms imply to us that the speaker sees the term “Jew” (and by extension, what that term stands for) as a dirty word.

“BUT WAIT” – I hear you say – “didn’t you just say that Jew is used as a slur?!?”

Yes. Yes, I did. And also, it is fundamentally offensive not to call us that, because it is our name and our identity.

Let me back up a little bit, and bring you into the world of one of those 2000s PSAs about not using “that’s so gay”. Think of some word that is your identity – something which you consider to be a fundamental and intrinsic part of yourself. It could be “female” or “male”, or “Black” or “white”, “tall” or “short”, “Atheist” or “Mormon” or “Evangelical” – you name it.

Now imagine that people started using that term as a slur.

“What a female thing to do!” they might say. “That teacher doesn’t know anything, he’s so female!”

Or maybe, “Yikes, look at that idiot who’s driving like an atheist. It’s so embarrassing!”

Or perhaps, “Oh gross, that music is so Black, turn it off!”

Now, what would you say if the same groups of people who had been saying those things for years turned around and avoided using those words to describe anything other than an insult?

“Oh, so I see you’re a member of the female persuasion!”

“Is he… a follower of the atheist beliefs? Like does he identify as part of the community of atheist-aligned individuals?”

“So, as a Black-ish identified person yourself – excuse me, as a person who comes from a Black-ish family…”

Here’s the fundamental problem with treating all words that are used as slurs the same, without any regard for how they are used and how they developed – not all slurs are the same.

No one, and I mean no one (except maybe for a small handful of angsty teens who are deliberately making a point of being edgy) self-identifies as a kike. In contrast, essentially all Jews self-identify as Jews. And when non-Jews get weird about that identity on the grounds that “Jew is used as a slur”, despite the fact that it is the name that the Jewish community as a whole resoundingly identifies with, what they are basically saying is that they think that the slur usage is more important than the Jewish community self-identification usage. They are saying, in essence, “we think that your name should be a slur.” 

Now, at the top I said that the word “Jew” and the word “queer” had some significant similarities in terms of their usage, and I think that’s pretty apparent if you look at what people in those communities are saying about those terms. When American Jews were being actively threatened by neo-Nazis in the 70s, the slogan of choice was “For every Jew a .22!″. When the American Queer community was marching in the 90s in protest of systemic anti-queer violence, the slogan of choice was “We’re here, we’re queer, get used to it!” Clearly, these are terms that are used by the communities themselves, in reference to themselves. Clearly, these terms are more than simply slurs.

But while there are useful similarities between how the terms “Jew” and “Queer” are used by bigots and by their own communities, I’d also like to point out that there is pretty substantial and important difference:

Unlike for “queer”, there is no organized group of Jewish antisemites who are using the catchphrase “Jew is a slur!” in order to selectively silence and disenfranchise Jews who are part of minority groups within Judaism. 

This is the real rub with the term queer – no one was campaigning about it being a slur until less than a decade ago. No one was saying that you needed to warn for the word queer when queer people were establishing the academic discipline of queer studies. No one was ‘think of the children”-ing the umbrella term when queer activists were literally marching for their lives. Go back to even 2010 and the term “q slur” would have been basically unparseable – if I saw someone tag something “q slur”, like most queer people I would have wracked my brains trying to figure out what slur even started with q, and if I learned that it was supposed to be “queer”, my default assumption would be that the post was made by a well-meaning but extremely clueless straight person.

I literally remember this shift – and I remember who started it. Exclusionists didn’t like the fact that queer was an umbrella term. Terfs (or radfems as they like to be called now) didn’t like that queer history included trans history; biphobes and aphobes didn’t like that the queer community was also a community to bisexuals and asexuals. And so what could they possibly say, to drive people away from the term that was protecting the sorts of queer people that they wanted to exclude?

Well, naturally, they turned to “queer is a slur.”

And here’s the thing – queer is a slur, just like Jew is a slur, and no one is denying that. And that fact makes “queer is a slur so don’t use it” a very convincing argument on the surface: 1) queer is still often used as a slur, and 2) you shouldn’t ever use slurs without carefully tagging and warning people about them (and better yet, you should never use them at all), and so therefore 3) you need to tag for “the q slur” and you need to warn people not to call the community “the queer community” or it’s members “queer people” or its study “queer studies” – because it’s a slur!

But the crucial step that’s missing here is exactly the same one above, for the word “Jew” – and that step is that not all slurs are the same. When a term is both used as a slur and used as a self-identity term, then favoring the slur meaning instead of the identity meaning is picking the side of the slur-users over the disadvantaged group! 

If you say or tag “q slur” you are sending the message, whether you realize it or not, that people who use “queer” as a slur are more right about its meaning than those who use it as their identity. Tagging for “queer” is one thing. People can filter for “queer” if it triggers them, just like people can filter for anything else. Not everyone has to personally use the term queer, or like the term queer. But there is no circumstance where the term “q slur” does not indicate that you think queer is more of a slur than of an accurate description of a community.

If I, as a Jew, ever came across a post where someone had warned for innocent, positive, non-antisemitic content relating to Judaism with the tag “J slur”, I would be incensed. So would any Jew. The act of tagging a post “J slur” is in and of itself antisemitic and offensive.

Queer people are allowed to feel the same about “q slur”. It is not a neutral warning term – it is an attack on our identity.

  • iridescent-lightning
    iridescent-lightning reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • somekindofmechanicalgirl
    somekindofmechanicalgirl reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • somekindofmechanicalgirl
    somekindofmechanicalgirl liked this · 5 months ago
  • randompersonontheinternet01
    randompersonontheinternet01 liked this · 5 months ago
  • slowpiracy
    slowpiracy liked this · 5 months ago
  • missewoodhouse
    missewoodhouse liked this · 5 months ago
  • emilieduchatele
    emilieduchatele liked this · 5 months ago
  • relevant-catnik
    relevant-catnik reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • snazzy-fangs
    snazzy-fangs reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • snazzy-fangs
    snazzy-fangs liked this · 5 months ago
  • approximately7bees
    approximately7bees liked this · 5 months ago
  • redshiftsinger
    redshiftsinger reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • the-spice-must-woah
    the-spice-must-woah reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • rumbleredee
    rumbleredee liked this · 5 months ago
  • doublene
    doublene reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • guidingarc
    guidingarc reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • cleverclara
    cleverclara reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • flowersforvax
    flowersforvax liked this · 5 months ago
  • wet-paiint
    wet-paiint liked this · 5 months ago
  • okspiders
    okspiders liked this · 5 months ago
  • adorbsstuffs
    adorbsstuffs liked this · 5 months ago
  • gaybugcentral
    gaybugcentral liked this · 5 months ago
  • warmhappycat
    warmhappycat reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • lualewis
    lualewis reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • tumultuwus
    tumultuwus liked this · 5 months ago
  • lualewis
    lualewis liked this · 5 months ago
  • fr-eck-less
    fr-eck-less liked this · 5 months ago
  • blurryphotosoffood
    blurryphotosoffood liked this · 5 months ago
  • neverenoughxp
    neverenoughxp reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • neverenoughxp
    neverenoughxp liked this · 5 months ago
  • fullofboredom
    fullofboredom reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • spiralsketchbook
    spiralsketchbook reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • fullofboredom
    fullofboredom liked this · 5 months ago
  • spiralsketchbook
    spiralsketchbook liked this · 5 months ago
  • silenttttt
    silenttttt reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • silenttttt
    silenttttt reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • silenttttt
    silenttttt liked this · 5 months ago
  • guidingarc
    guidingarc reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • gracelandmp3
    gracelandmp3 liked this · 5 months ago
  • spontaneousmusicalnumber
    spontaneousmusicalnumber reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • contentedcitrus
    contentedcitrus liked this · 5 months ago
  • a-boros-named-seamus
    a-boros-named-seamus liked this · 5 months ago
  • ground-zoro
    ground-zoro reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • dorianwrites
    dorianwrites liked this · 5 months ago
  • sp1derc1der
    sp1derc1der liked this · 5 months ago
  • luciensbabbles
    luciensbabbles reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • luciensbabbles
    luciensbabbles liked this · 5 months ago
  • foundmykeys
    foundmykeys reblogged this · 5 months ago
  • foundmykeys
    foundmykeys liked this · 5 months ago

More Posts from Feministdm

4 years ago

Nina Simone - The Desperate Ones

Just like the tiptoe moth That dance before the flame They burn their hearts so much That death is just a name And if love calls again So foolishly they run, they run, they run They run without a sound The desperate ones


Tags :
4 years ago
Obsessed With Eartha Kitts Absolute Power Move Of Risking Her Entire Career To Drag Lyndon B. Johnsons
Obsessed With Eartha Kitts Absolute Power Move Of Risking Her Entire Career To Drag Lyndon B. Johnsons

Obsessed with Eartha Kitt’s absolute power move of risking her entire career to drag Lyndon B. Johnson’s bitch ass so hard that his wife started crying


Tags :
4 years ago

How To Become a Myth

- Nikita Gill

1.

Fly into the sun, defy anyone who tells you that you cannot love Him.

The ocean will break your fall. even if it is by drowning you.

(You knew he would burn you, Icarus you simply thought he was worth the risk)

2.

Get stolen by a God away from the meadows you once knew, wood nymph.

Become Queen of the Underworld. Turn the land of the dead into home.

(You knew didn’t you, Kore? How to survive you would become Persephone?)

3.

Turn yourself into an echo of the person you used to be, then fall in love with him.

And when he doesn’t notice you Instead falls in love with himself, pine away.

(Narcissus could never love you, dear Echo. Not the way he loved himself.)

4.

Become an indestructible monster. Become the thing that warriors speak of in hushed breaths in terror.

When you finally do die at someone’s hands make sure it is glorious.

(Theseus was the only end worthy of you, Minotaur.)

5.

When the Sea God assaults you, turn people into stone. Turn Gods into stone.

Turn anything that threatens you ever again into stone.

(Medusa, Athena turned you monster to protect you. She took your beauty to give you power.)

6.

Adore her so much that the world grieves with your broken heart’s song.

Almost save her from the Underworld. Almost.

(Orpheus, all you had to do was not turn to look at her.)

7.

Marry a God King.

Watch him betray you over and over again. Become bitter and cruel.

Recognise he will never respect you. Promise to make him suffer till he does.

(Hera, I know why you couldn’t leave him, it was all for love, it was all for love)

8.

Become an undefeated warrior in a war where you lose everything you love.

Even the one you love most of all. Don’t realise it. Keep fighting.

(Achilles, Patroclus’ love would have made you immortal anyway.)

9.

Be unhappy in your marriage. Find a dangerous Prince who promises you a real love.

Run away with him

Do not think of the consequences.

(Helen, you didn’t just launch a thousand ships you set kingdoms ablaze.)

10.

Destroy everyone you love in a murderous rage.

Go on a journey hoping it will kill you

(Hercules tell the truth, you hoped those tasks would be your destruction didn’t you?)

Addendum:

Don’t become a myth. Stay human.

Stay mortal.

It is less wounds.

I promise. It is less wounds.


Tags :
4 years ago

I know TAZ has some completely epic lines that resonate with people like the “I saw seven birds” speech and “Our capacity for love increases” speech but what’s everyone’s favorite stupid line that for some reason lodged in your head beyond the others I’ll start 

Mine is when Taako and Barry are talking in the Beach Episode and Taako says “Barold… Barold…. I rolled an Eleven Barold, you have to tell me.”


Tags :
4 years ago

Fun fact: I’m autistic I’m gonna do a thing inspired by another person

Fun Fact: Im AutisticIm Gonna Do A Thing Inspired By Another Person

Reblog if your blog is safe for autistic people or is ran by an autistic person!

oh and

Fun Fact: Im AutisticIm Gonna Do A Thing Inspired By Another Person

Reblog if you stand against Autism Speaks!


Tags :