Fundy: Or You Can Bring Chaos And Destruction To The Dream SMP

Fundy: or you can bring chaos and destruction to the Dream SMP

Doesn’t that happen on a regular basis anyway?

I think it’s pretty safe to say that Foolish isn’t the mysterious 5th member of the Antarctic Syndicate, Harpocrates purely because of how Phil and him interacted. Which leaves a few candidates mainly: Dream (because him and Techno have worked together in the past), Puffy (Because of her hatred for the egg), Hannah (because of her association with roses) or Callahan (because he never talks and could keep secrets).

Personally I don’t think it will be Hannah or Puffy since when Techno talked about who it was he used ‘he’. So looking at the male members I don’t believe it could be: George, Sapnap, Sam, Jack, Connor, Vikk, Lazar, Charlie, Eret, HBomb or Purpled purely because of the lack of solid evidence.

However looking back at who Harpocrates is [god of silence and secrets in religion] and how he is symbolised [symbol is a rose] makes me think there is a possibility of him being Karl. In Tales From The SMP when Karl is in the Inbetween there are always Wither Roses also he has been shown to keep secrets close to his chest even from Sapnap and Quackity who are his fiancés.

Feel free to talk about you’re ideas I like reading them (you’re all really funny sometimes!) and if I end up being wrong then it is what it is.

EDIT: FOLLOW UP post about Karl’s connection to Kinoko Kingdom

Puffy's therapy office is already better than the one I go to irl

Ranboo: You're not gonna be ready for what I have planned

Ranboo... this fandom is never ready for anything even if you give us a week

Ghostbur: *shows up*

The fandom: I wanna see my little boy!

Foolish (clearly joking): and here’s the final control room!

Chat (who probably still has flashbacks):