Welp, I Guessed Right!

Welp, I guessed right!

My expectation was that Madoka and Homura would be in first and second (either for either spot), but it seems Madoka came in third instead! (Very surprising to me!)

Homura, because she's Homura.

Madoka, because she's the protagonist, has an iconic design, and is the center of the narrative. Madoka's a very lovable character in ways I can't exactly pinpoint.

Sayaka I had predicted to be third, but she's second! I had predicted her in third because of the amount of fanart and almost cult-following she has around her in the fandom (Sayaka fans are definitely the most dedicated and vocal in my experience)

Mami, Kyoko, and Nagisa I all predicted in their correct spots:

Mami is iconic for her unfortunate decapitation, her being the first proper magical girl we see, and generally getting a good amount of time to know her!

Kyoko suffers from the diseases of "not enough screen time" and "not enough focus" in the main show. She gets misrepresented as an accessory for Sayaka's narrative, but she has a standalone narrative and the same level of great writing as the rest of the girls. The full rant will not be here, but Kyoko is a good character and she needs more love.

Nagisa suffers from "condemned to side media"-itis. She was made simply because fans loved Charlotte, so I was very torn between thinking she'd be higher or lower. In the end I figured she'd be lowest since she really doesn't get much time to shine in the main story (not appearing in the main series and only showing up as a side character in one movie so far) and her backstory is hidden in Magia Record (RIP).

*NOT WHO YOU THINK THE FANBASE'S FAVORITE CHARACTER IS, WHO YOUR FAVORITE CHARACTER IS

Feeling inspired and creative. I'm going to try making more PMMM OCs, and I'm going to hope that nothing goes horribly awry like it did last time!

This is the link for the PMMM discord server! I saw a lot of people who didn't see the reblog version (the one with the link), so I put the link up here!

You don't need permission to join and anyone can join, feel free to share with your PMMM-loving mutuals!!!

There's channels for OCs, chatting, specific characters, and some more: and if I missed any important channels or roles you can feel free to message me in the server (+for any general requests)!

An edit to provide some more info:

You can join without interacting or posting anything: it's fine if you want to lurk!

The only hard rules are anti-NSFW and no harrassment or rudeness.

My brain is being ripped apart because I desperately want to make magical girl ocs and work on my magical girl projects but on the other hand I can't even begin to try and work on a magical girl thing without suffering

I don't know why, but recently I've been having really bad magical-girl burnout... I've been trying to work on pmmm ocs, ocs for personal magical girl projects, and really simple magical girl stuff in general but I've not been able to get into the zone at all. I'll probably not post for a bit (since this is a primarily magical girl blog), but I'll try to work on non-magical girl projects and see if it fixes anything.

I made this a few days ago and kept forgetting to post it, but here's Komoe's witch Velveteen!

"The witch of holes with a grateful nature.

She longs for the day a magical girl will come and end her. She understands, accepts, and embraces the fate and role of a witch: and happily lures magical girls to her labyrinth. The holes that cover her labyrinth are impossible to navigate in order to force all girls who enter to be or become magical girls to have any hope of escape."

EDIT: Slightly updated colors and textures to make it look nicer!

Here's a gem from the discord server

(Link if you want to join) →