Pll Theories - Tumblr Posts

Can we talk about the fact that Jenna raped Toby in s1 and nobody did anything about it?

Theory time (PLL: Original Sin)

I was a pre teen when I started watching the original PLL and I was obsessed with it back then, PLLOS has made its way into my adult life and now i’m obsessed with theorizing everything again so let’s go

At that beach scene Imogen is still wearing the clothes from Karen’s party which makes me think baby was conceived that night, so something happened either at the party or on the way home.

Tabby was SA’d that’s why she keeps the camera at the boy’s locker room, she’s probably trying to discover who was it and tbh I have a feeling it might be Noa’s boyfriend. The opening has a lot of futebol references

One of them is for sure helping A, that text message? “Reveal your true self, 1 bully down 5 to go” was shady asf

Minnie is off but I don’t think she has anything to do with A but something equally sinister has happened to her

Karen really died, Kelly planned her death. There was a lot of swapping that day but i’m sure Kelly is the evil twin, the way she told the ‘truth’ after her dad gave a speech about how he would end those girls life? self preservation, she needed him to stop digging further into her sisters death

The sheriff definitely has an affair with the principal. I said what I said

Angela was being followed by someone/threatened the night of the party

Also, that wasn’t a party. No one calling the cops or 911? no way, literally no way. I’m pretty sure it was just the moms and Angela that night, as Tabby’s mom said “they know what everyone thinks is the truth” there’s more to it.

Masked man and A are different people but work together

Now this is just a random thought, NO ONE NOTICE THE JANITOR IS GONE????

I need Imogen to be gay that’s it. that’s the comment.

There’s a teddy bear close to Angela’s memorial (?) below the scarlet letter book, masked man carries the same bear in the series intro

that’s it my inbox is open if anyone wants to discuss any of it <3

I watched ep. 4/5, now off to the theories & thoughts

I will never stop theorizing i’m so sorry.

When masked man opens Imogen’s basement door you can clearly see blood stains on the stairs, technically he didn’t murder anyone there as far as we know that blood must be Davie’s.

Also, is he protecting or trying to frame these girls? Apart from Noa, he got all of them in trouble after pushing Karen, Tabby can be easily target as a suspect if someone finds Tyler’s body. Idk, it just occurred to me.

Finally, there was a pic of two kids at masked man box so my guess is he is Angela Water’s brother which imo is Wes.

Last but not least, I need Imogen and Tabby to kiss. Like right this second. Both are too gay to be straight.