Quinn Fabray X Reader - Tumblr Posts

quinn fabray they could never make me hate you baby

rewrite the stars || quinn fabray

quinn fabray. you’re best friend. you both know that it’s much more, so does everyone else. so what’s the problem?

lately quinn has been distant, the only interaction you’ve had with her the past week was the few stares you had caught quinn in the middle of. everyone has been asking you what’s wrong and if she’s alright. every time you end up saying that you’re both ok and that she’s just busy with cheer stuff.

anytime you tried talking to her she just said she had to do something, like go to cheer or the bathroom. you kicked yourself about what happened a while ago. it wasn’t recently, but it couldn’t be ruled out completely.

one day when you were at quinn’s house. “what’s it like? being with a girl?” quinn looked up from her homework while sitting on her bed. you stumbled on your words before speaking a full sentence. probably because you were trying not to say ‘date me. it’s a win-win, you get to see if you like girls and i get to love you.’ but you didn’t. “it’s nice. why? you got a girl in mind?” you smiled at her. quinn’s expression turned from light and happy to uncomfortable. she shifted in her spot and brushed it off. “i... i don’t know. i mean, even if i did, i wouldn’t be able to do anything about it.” you squinted at her. “why not quinn?” she changed the subject and continued to brush it off. “eh i don’t know. do you need any help with your homework?”

one day in glee club, you decide to address it. you get there early, and end up explaining everything to puck and finn, your other friends. you only told part of what was going on. “she’s just been ignoring me the past week.” you say. “well i wouldn’t say ‘ignoring’. quinn’s been staring at you constantly. and i know stares, trust me, she’s in love with you.” puck thought the idea of you and quinn together was a match made in heaven. “yeah, i think puck’s right.” finn spoke up. “well if she is, i get why she’d ignore me, i mean the idea of being with another girl. she’s scared. quinn cares about status and in general it’s scary to try and figure out who you are.” you bit your lip and puck and finn exchanged glances. “and i have the perfect song to sing. i just hope quinn figures out when to join in. and this better work, i can’t lose quinnie.”

after mr. shue was done talking, you asked if you could sing a song. “of course y/n, go ahead.” he gave a smile, then went to the back of the room and sat down with the students. you felt quinn watching you, and looked at her for a moment before you started to sing.

you know i want you

it's not a secret i try to hide

i know you want me

so don't keep sayin' our hands are tied

you claim it's not in the cards

and fate is pullin' you miles away

and out of reach from me

but you're here in my heart

so who can stop me if i decide

that you're my destiny?

you saw quinn move her hair from her face only to show her tear up almost immediately. she knew, quinn knew that this was about her.

what if we rewrite the stars?

say you were made to be mine

nothing could keep us apart

you'd be the one i was meant to find

it's up to you, and it's up to me

no one can say what we get to be

so why don't we rewrite the stars?

maybe the world could be ours

tonight

your focus was on quinn completely, she’s the only person that could take your attention like that. that’s when you saw quinn shift in her seat before getting up and harmonizing. she stepped down onto the main floor and walked towards you.

you think it's easy

you think i don't wanna run to you

but there are mountains

and there are doors that we can't walk through

i know you're wondering why because we're able to be

just you and me within these walls

but when we go outside, you're gonna wake up and see

that it was hopeless after all

quinn’s voice had so much emotion. no matter what she sang, you felt everything. it was one of the things you admired most about her. she rarely sang something she didn’t mean, so it was a miracle quinn decided to join in.

no one can rewrite the stars

how can you say you'll be mine?

everything keeps us apart

and I'm not the one you were meant to find

it's not up to you

it's not up to me

when everyone tells us what we can be

how can we rewrite the stars?

say that the world can be ours

tonight

you’re voices were perfect together. this was the most nerve racking moment in your life, but you wanted to stay there in that moment forever. quinn grabbed your hand and her thumb rubbed the top of your hand. they fit perfectly together, like missing puzzle pieces.

all i want is to fly with you

all i want is to fall with you

so just give me all of you

it feels impossible

it's not impossible

is it impossible?

say that it's possible

how do we rewrite the stars?

say you were made to be mine?

nothing can keep us apart

'cause you are the one i was meant to find

it's up to you

and it's up to me

no one can say what we get to be

and why don't we rewrite the stars?

changing the world to be ours

quinn sang the last part and you knew this moment was going to end. great, now you started to tear up. there was still a chance that she wouldn’t be with you. you love each other, that was definitely clear. but would she accept it? would you still be friends? all you could do was hope.

you know i want you

it's not a secret i try to hide

but i can't have you

we're bound to break and my hands are tied

by this time you were both crying. sobbing, in fact. you fell into each other’s arms and held onto one another. “i missed you, so much.” she said between sobs. you felt her hand hold the back of your head. “i missed you too.” you both pulled away from the hug and held each other’s face in your hands. “quinn i love you. not just as friends, so much more. i need you in my life. i get if you don’t wanna be with me but i know you feel the same.” you looked into her eyes, as if the words would be written out. quinn’s eyes were looking at you the same way. “i love you.” you blurted out. she let out a shaky laugh. “i love you. i was ignoring you because i didn’t know how to tell you, and i was scared of being with a girl, especially you. but i don’t wanna hide how i feel anymore.” before she could let out another sob, you kissed her. she kissed back passionately. she moved her hand to the side of your head. sparks were flying, and you had butterflies in your stomach.

you both remembered that you were still in the room with the rest of the club and pulled away. you looked at the rest of the room and laughed, with quinn joining. every single person in the room was silent, their jaws gaping open. finally puck broke the silence and really quietly said, “no fucking way.” everyone lost it and started cheering and said some variation of “i knew it.”

hand in hand with quinn, you both sat down and quinn whispered in your ear; “i guess we rewrote the stars.”