Susannah Fisher - Tumblr Posts

if I see another ‘the summer I turned pretty’ fanfic with the title ‘Cruel Summer’ I might just lose it

locked in || j.f x fem!conklin reader

Warnings: cursing,smut, kinda dom!reader, reader is five months younger than belly, reader is on birth control. think that's all but please tell me if i'm missing anything!

Summary: Y/n and Jeremiah get locked in bathroom and has a deep conversation, and ends up getting steamy.

Requested: @t-t-070906

Word Count: 864

Me and Conrad have always been close. He is my ride or die. always telling each other everything. belly, my older sister, of course got jealous as a normal girlfriend would. but I have my eyes set on someone else.

Jeremiah fisher, the brother of conrad. We of course were friends, growing up together and all but, we never told each other our secrets. we just enjoyed each other company.

Belly and conrad had left for the beach. so i decided to finally so my hair counting that it's been a bun since we got here. I went to my room and saw that all my hair ties were gone, i probably left them in the bathroom like i always did.

I realized that jeremiah was in the bathroom, i knocked on the door and waited for a response. "yeah?" he yelled. "can i come in i left my hair ties in there." i called back. "yeah, sure." he yelled back. i opened the door and shut it, so no cold air would get in. i grabbed my hair ties and went to go open the door but it was like locked but it wasnt even locked!

"um jere the door wont open." i said nervously. "what?" he called out turning of the water off and grabbing the towel. "yeah it like its jammed" he opened the glass door. his chest was wet and shinny. i tried not to stare, but i kind of hard when it's jeremiah fisher.

"here let me try." he said and went to the door and yanked on it. i sighed. why me god, why me? "well i guess we have to wait till connie and belly get home." he said looking at me. i stared at my feet and shifted uncomfortably. "hey, i have a question." he said. "sure, what is it." i said. "why arent you close with me and just conrad?" he asked. my eyes widened, not expecting him to ask me this kind of question.

i deeply sighed. " i don't know jere, i'm just not." i said looking anywhere but his eyes. "y/n that's a shit answer. i know there is a reason." he said looking in my eyes. i mumbled an answer. "what was that y/n? i could hear you." he teased. i rolled my eyes. "fine. i said it's because i like you a lot." i said trying to ignore my burning cheeks.

he had that smirk that we all know and i hate. "shut the fuck up jeremiah" i huffed. he just moved my hair and came closer to my face. he looked at my lips and then my eyes. god.

he brought his lips to mine. he wrapped his arms around my waist, picking me up to put me of the counter. i ran my hand through his now damp hair and tugging a tad. he made a mixture of a whimper and moan sound. i smirked into the kiss as he kissed down my neck. he was about to take of my shirt but look up at me for permission to take it off. i nodded and he pulled my shirt and started sucking my boobs. i moan and grabbed his hair and bit my lip.

he went further down my body and took off my short and moved my underwear to the side. he took of the towel and pumped him self a few time before lining him self up. he look at me. " can i go ahead?" he asked politely, like he wasn't about fuck someone in a bathroom.

"go ahead jere." i bit my lip again. he entered him self in. i moan and rolled my hips. he started going faster making me moan even loader. the thought of belly and cornrad coming home and catching us make me even more turned on. he pounded into as i held on to the counter with a death grip.

i felt myself coming to my high. "jere can i cum?" i asked through moan. "hold on i about to cum too." he said. i just moaned and tried to wait. "go ahead, ready?" i nodded virtuously and gripped his shoulders. i felt him cum into me first, i came a few seconds later. i felt myself go numb and shake around his cock. i rolled my eyes into the back of my eyes. he took himself out and made sure to stay close to me as i came down from my high.

i put my legs down as he grabbed a wet wash cloth and wiped me down, making sure to wipe up the cum that was going down my leg. he helped me back into my clothes. "thank you." i said with a smile. "of course y/n/n." he smiled back at me with the bright teeth he has.

"y/n, jere, were back" conrad yelled. jere smiled at me and helped me off the counter and kissed my forehead. "can we meet up at the pool later tonight?" he asked. i smiled "sure, 8?" he nodded and tried to open the door again, and it fucking opened. we look at each other and laughed.

TAGLIST: @t-t-070906 @gillybear17 @cmac-writes

I will never understand how people still think Conrad is BETTER for Belly than Jeremiah. Conrad was Daisy Buchanan and Belly was Gatsby. Which is funny because of all the Gatsby references this season. Jeremiah always loved Belly. Everybody is saying no Jere only started liking Belly the “summer she turned pretty” but did you see the flashbacks, Jeremiah has always been in love with Belly but always put her before him even if it meant not being with her. Conrad played with Belly’s heart all of season 1. Them almost kissing and then Conrad being an ass about it. When Jeremiah and Belly kissed Jere checked with Belly the next day to make sure they were still okay. Both boys Jeremiah and Conrad thought the Debutant Ball was stupid only difference is that when Belly asked Jere he agreed even though nobody thought even his own mother that he would ever go to one. And everybody is saying how Jere reacted to finding out Belly and Conrad kissed was over the top and dramatic but when Conrad found out Belly and Jere had kissed before hand he was like okay… flash forward to season 2 episode 8 and Conrad’s reaction to seeing Belly and Jeremiah kissing. Yes Jere had a reaction to finding out Belly and Conrad kissed because Belly and him had been “together” even if they weren’t dating. And Conrad’s reaction was so much worse this season when him and Belly were no longer together. Also Conrad essentially slut shaming his brother, not okay. And when Jeremiah wanted to keep his distance from Belly when they went to find Conrad and he wanted to stay mad he couldn’t. But Conrad’s reaction to seeing Belly at the summer house : “What’s she doing here” like wtf do you think you are. Conrad doesn’t communicate with Belly, he thinks he knows her so well but in reality he really doesn’t. While Jeremiah is always there for Belly and communicates with her. Also Conrad telling both Belly and Jeremiah to “grow up” when in reality he needs to grow up. Even Belly told Jeremiah that they had grown up and things were different. And the whole funeral thing when Conrad tells Belly he knew it was a mistake starting something with her and that entire thing like why was everybody only mad at Belly, Conrad was also very much in the wrong here. Belly wasn’t trying to make that day about her. Susannah was literally Belly’s second mom. Susannah’s death was hard for all of them. And I’m not denying that Belly and Conrad had some cute moments but they were so toxic for each other and manipulative. The both of them. And Jere was also a bit “toxic” don’t get me wrong but if you compare how the two of them treat Belly it’s clear who treats her better. And in episode one of season two when Belly calls Jeremiah, she calls him first, Jere was like oh did Conrad not answer but Belly called him not Conrad. Belly and Jeremiah were always best friends and that’s the best way to turn into something more. So excuse me for being TEAM JEREMIAH all the way, since episode one.

I don’t think Jere had any right to be annoyed at Conrad for kissing belly. They weren’t significant others in any definition of the term, they had only kissed a few times, which he had done with several other people that summer. Jere hadn’t been hinting at all how he felt. In fact he had many opportunities to, at the bonfire before she met cam, but some other girl called him away and he went to flirt with her instead.

Conrad didn’t break up with belly at her prom, she broke up with him. He just wanted to go home to his mum and kept saying how bad he felt for letting her down on that night, he even asked her “don’t do this” but she left him. Conrad went home to his mum as much as he could, and we saw in season one how much he took care of her. But that doesn’t mean he wasn’t allowed to spend time with belly or that he should of spent that time with his mum instead, seeing belly and being supported by her was one of the only happy things he had in his life.

I do think that Jere needed permission to kiss belly after she broke up with Conrad. Sorry but, kissing your brothers ex, two months after they broke up and one month after your mum died isn’t something I believe is okay to do. Jere also does talk badly of Conrad, he tells belly that Conrad will break her heart, he also insults Conrad to his face and says he’s not someone he would ever want to know which is horrible.

He’s constantly telling people to grow up because that’s what he’s been forced to do, so he finds it difficult that others don’t have to do the same. He’s always been told by his dad and both mums that he has to look after everyone because he’s the oldest, even though it’s only by one year. That kind of pressure is insane for an 18 year old.

Him and Nicole were never exclusive or in a relationship, he does apologise for leading her on, and accepts accountability for that. But they were never exclusive, and Nicole even says that her feelings aren’t hurt, he just wasted her time. He shuts everybody out BECAUSE he puts them first, he doesn’t want to burden them with his problems. Which is why he doesn’t tell anyone about his mums cancer. I’m not saying it’s healthy or good, but it is coming from a place of care for others over himself. He’s been told he has to take care of them all, so he shields them from his problems.

His reaction and response to them kissing I feel was justified, they were kissing on his car, and campus, when they only broke up two months ago. And were together for at least six months and slept together. If you feel that you can rationalise Jeres reaction and say it’s normal for him to be pissed, when he had only shared a couple of kisses with belly. Then surely you can see why Conrad would be upset that his brother kissed his ACTUAL ex girlfriend. Who he had a serious relationship with.

No I very much see how Conrad being pissed that Jeremiah and Belly were kissing on his car is rational. I just feel that everything he said wasn’t justified. He slut shamed Jeremiah which is not okay. And I never said I don’t like Conrad. I understand Conrad. I just think that Jeremiah is better for Belly. Also the fact that the two of them slept together should have any impact on their other relationships. It was a special moment for them but does not mean they owe each other anything.

And I do think Jere being upset at Belly and Conrad kissing is valid too. Both boys have feelings for Belly so it’s going to be upsetting no matter who it is.

Jeremiah was very subtle with how he felt but if you remember the pool scene when Jeremiah is saying that he’s been waiting for his time. He had stepped back when she went after Cam and he stood back because he knew that Belly had been crushing on Conrad for years. But he felt that it was his chance to be something more.

The prom break up I do admit was very messy and unclear. Belly felt Conrad pulling away from her and thought he was breaking up with her. And Conrad wasn’t being very clear about the situation and he was walking people out because he was going through a lot. It was a bunch of miscommunication which is what I was saying in the first place. They communicated with each other poorly.

And I wasn’t saying that Conrad shouldn’t have spent any time with Belly, they were dating and I love that he went out of his way to be with her. But Jeremiah’s frustration of having to go through it (Susannah’s death) alone while Conrad was at school is also valid. And I know Conrad loved and cared for his mom but school took a toll on that. I’m not saying that he never went to visit his mom and brother but it was definitely rough on all of them.

Yes Jere does tell Belly that Conrad is going to break her heart, and we’ll be did. He was pissed that he was losing Belly to Conrad and that his mom was dying. But he never talks bad about him to other people besides that. And yes Jeremiah says some really cruel things to Conrad this season and I’m not trying to excuse him for this but Conrad did belittle Jeremiah’s emotions. When Belly told Conrad that Jeremiah had told Belly that he had feeling for them and that they had kissed, Conrad says that Jeremiah won’t care because he doesn’t take anything seriously and flirts with everybody. But when Jeremiah was “with” Belly he was very loyal to her.

And yes while Nicole and Conrad were never really official or exclusive they were still “seeing” each other. And being led on by someone for them to text somebody else you’ve become close to that what they said earlier was a lie and he really wanted to ask her. Also after telling Nicole that he was going to ask Belly ONLY because his mom was making him.

On the aspect of him telling people to grow up though, I don’t entirely agree with you there. Conrad might of had to grow up sooner than he should have but so did Jeremiah. Jere was literally handling Susannah’s medical bills and the insurance. Which no kid should have to do. But as somebody who went through something “similar” in a way where I had to grow up before I should of had to at 9 I can’t understand fully Conrad’s behavior.

And I do agree that the parents are way too hard on him but sometimes that comes with being the oldest, which doesn’t make it okay. But Adam (the boys dad) was also never so easy on Jeremiah either. He constantly compared them to each other and made Jere feel bad that he wasn’t athletic and that he wasn’t playing football.

Conrad walling people off was not entirely him trying to protect them. I do think it was his own coping mechanism though. And I mean a lot of people do it. But I understand how the people around him felt hurt by him when he did it. He should have told his mom that he knew about the cancer, that way Susannah not Conrad had to go through all that alone. And I do think that Conrad should have told Jeremiah about it as well but I also see how it’s not his place to tell him. But again I’m not saying Conrad is doing it to be mean but that’s how a lot of people first hand may end of viewing it.

Also I never said nor will I ever say that Conrad doesn’t put other people first it’s just in a very different way and people may not know it.

All I’m saying is that Jeremiah and Belly are the better couple. All three of them have their issues and flaws that they need to work on but they also have beautiful things about them.