Brokenstar Was Scummy, But He Was Seriously A Good Villain. Thistle Did Nothing Really Big Or Threatening

Brokenstar was scummy, but he was seriously a good villain. Thistle did nothing really big or threatening ON HIS OWN save for being a greasy creep, and thus fell short as a villain.

Seething hot take. Thistleclaw was good…at being a horrible cat who you just wanted karma to whoop him. In my opinion, he was supposed to be a bad cat, one of the worst. But the issue is not only was Spottedleaf’s Heart handling sensitive topics poorly or worse, unknowingly, the Erin’s crossed the thin line between Palpatine and Kylo Ren. Villain who you want defeated badly and a loathesome uncomfortable character you never wanna see again.

Not to mention he gets murked offscreen, which ain’t satisfying at all.

Making it clear, I don’t support his actions but he kinda just…fell flat on his face when it came to being a good villain. Hope he actually gets his ass handed to him in a meaningful scene instead of just kinda lingering about.

So remember the frecklewish thing?

Starclan tweeted her into the dark forest for not doing anything when Maple’s kits drowned. K so uh

Didn’t they tell Pinestar to kill his own child? I think about it, sometimes.

It’s so hard to talk about him or even express interest in Thistleclaw as a villain in Bluestar’s prophecy when Spottedleaf’s heart is breathing on your shoulder. Because he could be really interesting to bring up! I was considering comparing him to Bojack with how much of a bad person he is, but SH completely ruins it. You mention his name once and suddenly it feels like you’re on thin ice. 

Here it is. My hottest take of all; Spottedleaf’s Heart DID ruin Thistleclaw… because it made him the wrong kind of bad.

In Bluestar’s Prophecy, Thistleclaw is well characterized as violent and petulant. He sabotages Bluefur’s hunting, loses his temper constantly, and refuses to ever take responsibility for his actions or influence by pinning blame on others.

He isn’t some master manipulator with a silver tongue. He couldn’t even turn his own son against Bluefur. He’s your racist uncle ranting about RiverClan at the dinner table, the kind of dangerous that rallies other xenophobes and puts bad thoughts into lonely teenagers. When he meets his death in that border battle, it’s only him who dies, because he never got the power to get other cats killed with his short-sighted bloodlust.

So PUTTING ASIDE everything else atrocious about Spottedleaf’s Heart, there was no reason to add pedophilia to this. Now every discussion about Thistleclaw is obviously about this, outpacing every other aspect of his character, when it was not part of his villainy in any capacity before this wretched book.

Now you can’t have interesting discussions about Thistleclaw without this awful elephant in the room, like, “What did ThunderClan admire about him, enough to respect him as a potential deputy? What does this say about clan culture?“ or “Where does StarClan draw the line on violence and xenophobia?“ or “Is Tigerclaw just like Thistleclaw, but with the brains or guts to accomplish his goals? Would Whitestorm have been like him if he didn’t have Bluefur?“ or “Was Thistleclaw truly evil, or just a generally awful person?“

Gone! Out the window! He’s so bad he’s pedo-bad. It adds nothing except incredible discomfort! Thistleclaw didn’t NEED ‘more reasons‘ to be sent to the Dark Forest, he was already a bad guy! COMMIT to the reasons already present! Christ!!

Those fake chaos emeralds seemed to project mostly dark or negative feelings. Dark Gaia also uses those…..HMMMMM.

Sandgorse Slander

Sandgorse is the Buck Cluck of Warriors and you can’t tell me I’m wrong.

Evil cats are fun.