
she/herBlog for opinions on tv shows, being a writer, bad philosophy takes, and other random things from yours truly π³βπ
422 posts
Who Vs Why
Who vs Why

Ruby kept focusing on 'who' and not 'why' in regard to her birth mother and it drove me wild.
Does the 'who' technically make sense for the overarching storyline? Yes! They clearly understood that this myth of Ruby's birth mother needed to up be built up both for the audience and for the characters.
BUT, that gets lost when they're constantly focused on who Ruby's birth mother was, especially towards the end. It's more interesting as to why she left her at the church on Christmas.
What was so special about Christmas? About that church? Why would a woman abandon a complete newborn?
If they had stuck specifically to why she was left that still would've played into the legend. Maybe Ruby kept making stories up when she was a child, that her birth mother had some secret mission and had to leave Ruby there or SOMETHING because that's what children do!
So to find out how normal her birth mother is, it's both confusion but also a slight relief because Ruby realizes that her birth mother was just a girl like her.
It makes that reveal with Louise at the end more impactful because let's be honest, they brushed over that so fast.
This also helps to align Ruby's story more with the Doctor. The Doctor wants to know why his parents left him on that planet. Yes, who is important, but why? Why there? Why then? That is so much more interesting and compelling.
Maybe the Doctor has started to make up stories in his own mind about who they are. They could've had such a wonderful scene where Ruby shares the little stories she's made up over the years.
Also, side note and I'm not going to get personal, but I do have other issues with the way Louise was presented as Ruby's "mother" and not "birth mother". I give RTD the benefit of the doubt as he did address that in commentary (though it wasn't the best response).
-
thewalkindudette liked this · 7 months ago
-
lisa-uepp liked this · 7 months ago
-
theheroheart liked this · 8 months ago
-
whovian2325 liked this · 8 months ago
-
underrcanyonlou liked this · 8 months ago
-
dreamsfrozenincandyland reblogged this · 8 months ago
-
dreamsfrozenincandyland liked this · 8 months ago
-
cinammoncreeps liked this · 8 months ago
-
occamschainsaws liked this · 8 months ago
-
somethinggotoutofthepaintings reblogged this · 8 months ago
-
annxxwin liked this · 8 months ago
-
genderqueerpond liked this · 8 months ago
-
mothcryptid1998 liked this · 8 months ago
More Posts from Thebadphilosopher

Season 2 is going to be the make it or break it season.
It's good or it's not.
There were so many issues in the first season, but I still have hope especially seeing the bts of everything so far π€
LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOO

DRACULA'S EX-GIRLFRIEND is coming 13th of September to Nebula!
Two former rivals reconnect over drinks and a quick bite.
One is compulsively running through men and canβt kick the habit of drinking their blood; the other is working through her trauma and lives with werewolves in LA.
Things get uncomfortable when the conversation turns to the same toxic lover that connected them β Count Dracula!
Full trailer drops next week!
AND
WE'RE HAVING A PREMIERE IN FUCKING HOLLYWOOD
THAT YOU CAN WIN FREE TICKETS TO
stay tuned to find out how!
It's funny seeing Galadriel being on Gil-Galad's side when last season she would have gladly have strangled him if it meant she got her way
i firmly believe that nobody ever intended for any iteration of Elrond to be a massive fan favourite but we all took one look and went "him. thats the one. he's the chosen one."

While it had its low points in terms of storytelling, Echo was one of the best Marvel projects I had seen for a long time, TV show OR movie.
I'm torn because I want a second season to explore Maya's powers and her changed relationships but also it was so good as a miniseries.
Hopefully Maya will be in an upcoming movie first.